This is an interesting twist on the discussion over gun control currently taking place. It’s basically a review of an album. The line that jumped off the page for me is where the author says 1/3 of his mind, while sitting in his Baltimore classroom as an inner city teen, was focussed on personal safety and only 2/3 on the work at hand. Wow. There is no use in comparing the value of one child’s loss versus another. So an analogy to Sandy Hook would be inappropriate. What is appropriate is to fold the impact on inner city students into the conversations now taking place in Washington. And to know that the artist isn’t glorifying violence, but questioning its effects.
By TA-NEHISI COATES
The work of the rapper Kendrick Lamar should enjoy heavy rotation in the White House these days. In this time of Tucson, Aurora, Colo., and Newtown, Conn., Lamar’s major-label debut album, “good kid, m.A.A.d city,” gives us a broad reckoning with the meaning of everyday gun violence unfolding far from the tragic spectacle. “Good Kid” has earned its share of praise from critics and hip-hop fans, but it perhaps has the most to offer to those shocked into action by the senseless massacres we’ve endured over the past few years.
Lamar’s album begins in such a place and tells the story of a teenage boy pursuing a girl with a mix of affection and lust. The character’s ordinary ambition differs little from that of teenagers who once piled into their parents’ car and turned the drive-in into a bacchanal. But Lamar’s lover’s lane runs through gang-infested Compton, Calif., and the make-out point is a deathtrap.
Hip-hop originates in communities where such hazards are taken as given. Rappers generally depict themselves as masters, not victims, of the attending violence. Their music is not so much interested in exalting to our preferred values as constructing a fantasy wherein the author has total control and is utterly invulnerable.
When your life is besieged, the music is therapy, vicarious mastery in a world where you control virtually nothing, least of all the fate of your body. I had a friend in middle school who would play Rakim every morning because he knew there was a good chance that he would be jumped en route to or from school by the various crews that roamed the area. But, in his mind, the mask of rap machismo made him too many for them.
“Good Kid” is narrative told from behind the mask. Fantasies of rage and lust are present, but fear pervades Lamar’s world. He pitches himself not as “Compton’s Most Wanted” but as “Compton’s Human Sacrifice.” He loves the city, even as he acknowledges that the city is trying to kill him. “If Pirus and Crips all got along,” he says, “They’d probably gun me down by the end of this song.”
On one of the most affecting songs, “The Art of Peer Pressure,” he engages in a series of criminal escapades. It’s reminiscent of N.W.A.’s “Gangsta, Gangsta,” except that Lamar is not a supercriminal but a boy out to impress his friends. The character’s drug use is not so much a choice of pleasure as it is a puerile bid for attention: “Look at me,” he raps. “I got the blunt in my mouth.”
I must confess my bias. I grew up in Baltimore during a time when the city was in the thrall of crack and Saturday night specials. I’ve spent most of my life in neighborhoods suffering their disproportionate share of gun violence. In each of these places it was not simply the deaths that have stood out to me, but the way that death corrupted the most ordinary of rituals. On an average day in middle school, fully a third of my brain was obsessed with personal safety. I feared the block 10 times more than any pop quiz. My favorite show in those days was “The Wonder Years.” When Kevin Arnold went to visit his lost-found love Winnie Cooper, he simply hopped on his bike. In Baltimore, calling upon our Winnie Coopers meant gathering an entire crew. There was safety in numbers. Alone, we were targets.
The world I lived in, and the preserve of Lamar’s album, was created not by mindless nature but by public policy. It is understandable that in the wake of great tragedy we’d want to take a second look at those policies. But in some corners of America great tragedy has bloomed into a world that does not simply raise the ranks of the dead but shrinks the world of the survivors. “Good Kid” shows us how gun violence extends out beyond the actual guns.
Here is an album that people grappling with policy desperately need to hear. It does what art does best in that it bids the monotony of numbers to sing.